Superconductivity is the phenomenon that happens when some electrical conductors are cooled down to very low temperatures, triggering the transmission of electricity without any resistive losses. This is a significant advantage: in the case of conventional technologies, power losses range from 2 to 5 per cent for a typical High-Voltage Direct-Current (HVDC) overhead line, and can be as high as 10 per cent for HVDC underground cables. ‘Lossless’ electricity transmission would translate into increased profitability and less wasted energy.
Electricity transport at -253oC
Since its discovery more than a century ago, superconductivity has found many applications, from particle accelerators to medical imaging equipment. In the last two decades, new findings have opened the way to developing superconductivity for electricity transport, as materials have been found with higher ‘critical temperatures’, thus making it easier and cheaper to reach the state of zero resistance. From these, the IASS has selected the superconducting material ‘magnesium-diboride’ (or MgB2), a recently discovered compound that can be readily produced at commercial level using widely available raw materials. It is also cheaper and more flexible than any other competing superconductor. Compared to the expensive, ceramics-based ‘High Temperature Superconductors’ with operating temperatures of 50–70 kelvin (K) (around -200oC), MgB2 has a lower critical temperature. Yet it can be easily manufactured into wires, an essential requirement for power lines.
The IASS cable design, which is based on an original idea by Nobel Laureate and IASS Scientific Director Carlo Rubbia, would consist of a Direct-Current (DC) cable setup supplied with a closed loop cryogenic system using either hydrogen or helium to maintain the operating temperature of ~20 K or -253oC. The cable is intended for lengths of hundreds or thousands of kilometres, and would achieve capacities of up to 10 Gigawatts (GW), or possibly even more. By way of comparison, a typical nuclear power plant has a generating capacity of 1–2 GW.
Small cables, large amounts of power
Because of the cryogenic insulation, superconducting cables are best installed underground. This means that superconducting lines would provide the same benefits as standard HVDC underground cables do vis-à-vis overhead lines: above all, a smaller ecological footprint and minimised visual impact. Furthermore, underground cables are not vulnerable to storm damage, they do not emit noise and require less land use.
But the distinct advantage of superconducting lines is their size: because they do not generate significant heat, large amounts of power can be transferred using single, small cables. We expect that the whole installation for a 4 GW, 800-km-long MgB2 cable would have a total diameter of 30 cm, which is much smaller than a conventional HVDC cable with a similar capacity, and vastly smaller than the corridor width needed for an overhead line. This could prove to be a decisive factor with respect to public acceptance. In Germany for instance, the planned SuedLink power line has sparked popular protests motivated in particular by concerns over electromagnetic fields, dropping property values and the visual impact of massive electricity pylons.
A cost-effective option
Finally, the first estimates conducted by the IASS – which are based on extrapolations from our prototype cable, material costs, etc. – show that MgB2 cables would be several times cheaper than standard HVDC cables, and could possibly compete with HVDC overhead lines.
This research project is carried out in cooperation with the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN) in Geneva, where laboratory experiments have been carried out over the last two years on progressively longer and more powerful wires. In February 2014, a significant breakthrough occurred when a 20m-long, 16-cm wide prototype cable carried a current of 20 000 amperes, a world record for a superconductor. This success is an important step in the R&D process, setting the course for larger scale experiments. To this end, the IASS has been establishing a network with relevant stakeholders all across Europe: research institutions, cable manufacturers, government agencies, and transmission operators. This has enabled the scientists to gain a better understanding of how MgB2 superconducting lines could fit into the energy grid of the future, and what concrete economic, technical and social conditions are required for their large-scale implementation. Together with these partners, the IASS is also part of a European 7th Framework Programme project in which a demonstrator superconducting cable will be built and tested in operational conditions.
Photos: © CERN